Cataro’s Italian Villa is a pizza restaurant in West Allis, holding a 4.6-star rating across 412 Google reviews. Enduring neighborhood fixture serving thin-crust & deep-dish pizzas, along with other Italian fare. The space has a warm and cozy character that keeps diners coming back. The kitchen stays open late for a proper meal after a long night out. The restaurant is welcoming to families and younger diners. Prices are in the $$ range. Reservations are accepted.